Hayes: (To Pierce) I don’t know what you’re complaining about anyway. Personally, I’d rather be here than be in the League of Forgotten Vice-Presidents. I hear that’s a sorry group…
Fillmore: Hey! I’m in that League!
Hayes: (Gesturing to Fillmore) See what I mean?
Fillmore: I wouldn’t talk, Rutherfraud B. Hayes!
Hayes: (Jumps to his feet, pointing at Fillmore) My election was legitimate!
Fillmore: There were 4,287,670 Americans in 1876 who could beg to differ. Not to mention Samuel Tilden…
Hayes: I won the electoral vote!
Fillmore: (Also getting to his feet) Through voter fraud. And then an electoral commission was created to investigate. Eight Republicans, seven Democrats– yeah, guess who they gave the presidency to.
Hayes: Lies! I’m a model citizen. I don’t even drink!
Pierce: (Clearly enjoying the commotion) How do you live?
Tyler: (Raising his hand) Can I say something?
Fillmore and Hayes: No!
Tyler: (Quickly puts his hand down) Right.
Harrison: (Banging his gavel) Order gentlemen, order! This squabbling is pointless!
(Knock is heard at the door)
Harrison: (Shouting) WHO IS IT?!
(21st President Chester Arthur pops his head into the room)
Chester Arthur: Hey, could you gentlemen keep it down a little? We’re meeting in the next room.
Harrison: What meeting is that?
Arthur: (Fluffing his whiskers) The Presidents with Cool Facial Hair Society. President Lincoln is about to give a speech about beard grooming. Should be exciting.
Hayes: (Pulling on his beard) Hey, why wasn’t I invited?
Arthur: Beats me, Rutherfraud. Ciao! (Exits)
Hayes: (Angrily) Hey!
Harrison: Can we proceed now?
(General murmur of assent)
Harrison: Thank you. President Tyler, as League secretary, could you read the minutes of last week’s meeting?
Tyler: (Shuffling through some papers) Minutes…minutes…Ah yes, here we are. (Reading from paper) The meeting was called to order by President Harrison at 7:01 p.m. At 7:05, we recited the Pledge of Allegiance. Harrison then called roll. At 7:07, President Pierce made a motion that he be allowed to leave the League due to his popularity and good looks. No one seconded the motion. At 7:10, Harrison read the list of accomplishments of the Pierce administration. Five seconds later, the list was concluded…
(Fillmore and Hayes snicker.)
Harrison: (Sighing) Please continue, President Tyler.
Tyler: Ah, yes. (Finding his place on the page) At 7:12 p.m., President Fillmore made a remark concerning Pierce’s mother. At this point, Harrison excused himself to go to the bathroom and did not return to the meeting. A heated discussion ensued thereafter in which many…unprintable words were exchanged. During the…discussion, Pierce referred to President Hayes as “Rutherfraud.” At this point, Hayes entered the discussion by punching Pierce on the nose. The discussion and the meeting were concluded at 7:26 p.m. when Fillmore threw a chair through one of the windows.
Fillmore: Humph. I see they still haven’t repaired that window yet…
Hayes: (To Tyler) Where were you when all of this was going on?
Tyler: Under the table taking notes.
Harrison: Your dedication to your office is commendable.
Tyler: Uh, thanks.